Performing a Synchronous Spawn Under Win32s

The information in this article applies to:

• Microsoft Win32s, versions 1.30, 1.30a, 1.30c

SUMMARY

Under Windows NT, you can synchronously spawn an application (that is, spawn an application and wait until the spawned application is terminated before continuing). To do so, call CreateProcess() to start the application, and pass the handle returned to WaitForSingleObject() to wait for the application to terminate, or you could use the C run-time (CRT) function, _spawnl() with _P_WAIT from a Win32-based application. The former approach is shown in the sample code in the "More Information" section in this article.

However, this method does not work under Win32s. Under Win32s, CreateProcess() does not return the process handle for 16-bit Windows-based applications, only for Win32-based application. Even if it did, the method described in the proceeding paragraph would not work under Win32s because WaitForSingleObject() returns TRUE immediately under Win32s.

In fact, there is no 32-bit only solution for this issue. The 32-bit WinExec() does not return an instance handle as the 16-bit WinExec() does. In addition, you cannot use GetExitCodeProcess() to find the exit status of 16-bit Windows-based applications in order to loop on their status. It is a limitation that GetExitCodeProcess() returns zero for 16-bit Windows-based applications on both Windows NT and Win32s.

The solution is to create a thunk to the 16-bit side and from the 16-bit side, solve the problem as you would normally solve it from a Windows-based application. Namely, start the application with WinExec() and use one of the Toolhelp APIs in a test loop to determine when the application is terminated. Alternatively, you can use EnumWindows() to determine when the application is terminated. The sample code below uses the Toolhelp APIs.

MORE INFORMATION

Sample code to perform a synchronous spawn is given below. The code is divided into three source files:

• The main application.
• The 32-bit side of the thunk.
• The 16-bit side of the thunk.

In all three modules, use the following header file SPAWN.H:

/*** Function Prototypes ****/

/*** Constants for Dispatcher ***/

#define SYNCHSPAWN     1

Main Application

This application attempts to synchronously spawn NOTEPAD under Windows NT and Win32s. NOTE: Under Win32s, NOTEPAD is a 16-bit application.

GetVersion() is used to detect the platform. Under Windows NT, CreateProcess() and WaitForSingleObject() perform the spawn. Under Win32s, the thunked routine SynchSpawn() is called.

/*** Main application code ***/

#include <windows.h>
#include "spawn.h"

void main()

   DWORD dwVersion;
   STARTUPINFO si = {0};
   PROCESS_INFORMATION pi = {0};

   dwVersion = GetVersion();

   if( !(dwVersion & 0x80000000) )  // Windows NT
   {
      si.cb = sizeof(STARTUPINFO);
      si.lpReserved = NULL;
      si.lpReserved2 = NULL;
      si.cbReserved2 = 0;
      si.lpDesktop = NULL;
      si.dwFlags = 0;

      CreateProcess( NULL,
                     "notepad",
                     NULL,
                     NULL,
                     TRUE,
                     NORMAL_PRIORITY_CLASS,
                     NULL,
                     NULL,
                     &si,
                     &pi );
      WaitForSingleObject( pi.hProcess, INFINITE );
   }
   else if( LOBYTE(LOWORD(dwVersion)) < 4 )  // Win32s
   {
      SynchSpawn( "notepad.exe", SW_SHOWNORMAL );
   }

   MessageBox( NULL, "Return from SynchSpawn", " ", MB_OK );

32-bit Side of Thunk

This DLL provides the 32-bit side of the thunk. If the DLL is loaded under Win32s, it initializes the thunk in its DllMain() by calling UTRegister(). The entry point SynchSpawn() packages up the arguments and calls the 16-bit side through the thunk.

/*** Code for 32-bit side of thunk ***/

#define W32SUT_32    // Needed for w32sut.h in 32-bit code

#include <windows.h>
#include "w32sut.h"
#include "spawn.h"

typedef BOOL (WINAPI * PUTREGISTER) ( HANDLE     hModule,
                  LPCSTR     lpsz16BitDLL,
                  LPCSTR     lpszInitName,
                  LPCSTR     lpszProcName,
                  UT32PROC * ppfn32Thunk,
                  FARPROC    pfnUT32Callback,
                  LPVOID     lpBuff
                );

typedef DWORD (APIENTRY *PUT32CBPROC) (LPVOID lpBuff, DWORD dwUserDefined);

UT32PROC      pfnUTProc = NULL;
PUTREGISTER   pUTRegister = NULL;

PUT32CBPROC   pfnUT32CBProc = NULL;
int           cProcessesAttached = 0;
BOOL          fWin32s = FALSE;
HANDLE        hKernel32 = 0;

/********************************************************************\
* Function: BOOL APIENTRY DllMain(HANDLE, DWORD, LPVOID)             *
*                                                                    *
*  Purpose: DLL entry point. Establishes thunk.                      *

   DWORD dwVersion;

   if ( fdwReason == DLL_PROCESS_ATTACH )
   {

    /*
     * Registration of UT need to be done only once for first
     * attaching process.  At that time set the fWin32s flag
     * to indicate if the DLL is executing under Win32s or not.
     */

      if( cProcessesAttached++ )
      {
         return(TRUE);         // Not the first initialization.
      }

      // Find out if we're running on Win32s
      dwVersion = GetVersion();
      fWin32s = (BOOL) (!(dwVersion < 0x80000000))
                        && (LOBYTE(LOWORD(dwVersion)) < 4);

      if( !fWin32s )
         return(TRUE);         // Win32s - no further initialization needed

      hKernel32 = LoadLibrary( "Kernel32.Dll" ); // Get Kernel32.Dll handle

      pUTRegister = (PUTREGISTER) GetProcAddress( hKernel32, "UTRegister"

      if( !pUTRegister )
         return(FALSE);        // Error- Win32s, but can't find UTRegister

      pUTUnRegister = (PUTUNREGISTER) GetProcAddress(hKernel32,
                                                     "UTUnRegister");

      if( !pUTUnRegister )
         return(FALSE);        // Error- Win32s, but can't find

      return (*pUTRegister)( hInst,           // Spawn32.DLL module handle
                             "SPAWN16.DLL",   // 16-bit thunk dll
                             "UTInit",        // init routine
              "UTProc",        // 16-bit dispatch routine
                             &pfnUTProc,      // Receives thunk address
                             pfnUT32CBProc,   // callback function
                             NULL );          // no shared memroy

   }
   if((fdwReason==DLL_PROCESS_DETACH)&&(0==--cProcessesAttached)&&fWin32s)
   {
      (*pUTUnRegister)( hInst );
      FreeLibrary( hKernel32 );
   }

/********************************************************************\
* Function: DWORD APIENTRY SynchSpawn(LPTSTR, UINT)                  *
*                                                                    *
* Purpose: Thunk to 16-bit code                                      *

   DWORD Args[2];
   PVOID Translist[2];

   Args[0] = (DWORD) lpszCmdLine;
   Args[1] = (DWORD) nCmdShow;

   Translist[0] = &Args[0];
   Translist[1] = NULL;

   return( (* pfnUTProc)( Args, SYNCHSPAWN, Translist) );

16-bit Side of Thunk

This DLL provides the 16-bit side of the thunk. The LibMain() and WEP() of this 16-bit DLL perform no special initialization. The UTInit() function is called during thunk initialization; it stores the callback procedure address in a global variable. The UTProc() function is called with a code that indicates which thunk was called as its second parameter. In this example, the only thunk provided is for SynchSpawn(). The synchronous spawn is performed in the SYNCHSPAWN case of the switch statement in the UTProc().

NOTE: UTInit() and UTProc() must be exported. This can be done in the module definition (.DEF) file.

/* Code for 16-bit side of thunk.                              */
/* Requires linking with TOOLHELP.LIB, for ModuleFindHandle(). */

#define APIENTRY

#define W32SUT_16     // Needed for w32sut.h in 16-bit code

#include <windows.h>
#include <toolhelp.h>
#include <malloc.h>
#include "w32sut.h"
#include "spawn.h"

/********************************************************************\
* Function: LRESULT CALLBACK LibMain(HANDLE, WORD, WORD, LPSTR)      *
*                                                                    *
*  Purpose: DLL entry point                                          *

int FAR PASCAL LibMain( HANDLE hLibInst, WORD wDataSeg,
         WORD cbHeapSize, LPSTR lpszCmdLine)
{
   return (1);

/********************************************************************\
* Function: DWORD FAR PASCAL UTInit(UT16CBPROC, LPVOID)              *
*                                                                    *
*  Purpose: Universal Thunk initialization procedure                 *

   glpfnUT16CallBack = lpfnUT16CallBack;
   return(1);   // Return Success

/********************************************************************\
* Function: DWORD FAR PASCAL UTProc(LPVOID, DWORD)                   *
*                                                                    *
*  Purpose: Dispatch routine called by 32-bit UT DLL                 *

   switch (dwFunc)
   {
      case SYNCHSPAWN:
      {
          HMODULE hMod;
          MODULEENTRY FAR *me;
          UINT hInst;
          LPCSTR lpszCmdLine;
          UINT nCmdShow;
          MSG msg;
          BOOL again=TRUE;

          /* Retrieve the command line arguments stored in buffer */

          lpszCmdLine = (LPSTR) ((LPDWORD)lpBuf)[0];
          nCmdShow = (UINT) ((LPDWORD)lpBuf)[1];

          /* Start the application with WinExec() */

          hInst = WinExec( lpszCmdLine, nCmdShow );
          if( hInst < 32 )
             return 0;

          /* Loop until the application is terminated. The Toolhelp API
           * ModuleFindHandle() returns NULL when the application is
           * terminated. NOTE: PeekMessage() is used to yield the
           * processor; otherwise, nothing else could execute on the
           * system.
           * /

          hMod = GetModuleHandle( lpszCmdLine );

          me = (MODULEENTRY FAR *) _fcalloc( 1, sizeof(MODULEENTRY) );
          me->dwSize = sizeof( MODULEENTRY );
          while( NULL != ModuleFindHandle( me, hMod ) && again )
          {
             while( PeekMessage( &msg, NULL, 0, 0, PM_REMOVE ) && again )
             {
                if(msg.message == WM_QUIT)
                {
                   PostQuitMessage(msg.wParam);
                   again=FALSE;
                }
                TranslateMessage(&msg);
                DispatchMessage(&msg);
             }
          }
          return 1;
      }

   } // switch (dwFunc)

   return( (DWORD)-1L ); // We should never get here.

/********************************************************************\
* Function: int FAR PASCAL _WEP(int)                                 *
*                                                                    *
*  Purpose: Windows exit procedure                                   *

int FAR PASCAL _WEP( int bSystemExit )

   return (1);

REFERENCES:

For more information on the limitation of the C run-time (CRT) function, _spawnl() with the _P_WAIT parameter under Win32s, please refer to the following Knowledge Base article:

  ARTICLE ID: Q125213
  PRB: Spawn with _P_WAIT Returns Immediately on Win32s