FIX: Using "!" & "$?" Do Not Work as Expected w/ NMAKE 1.11

ID: Q61808

The information in this article applies to:

Microsoft NMAKE Utility for MS-DOS, version 1.11
Microsoft NMAKE Utility for OS/2, version 1.11

SYMPTOMS

In an NMAKE description file, applying the "!" (exclamation point) operator to the beginning of a command line using the macro "$?" should cause the command to be executed once for every out-of-date dependent file. In version 1.11 of NMAKE (shipped with C version 6.00), the $? macro evaluates to the list of every dependent, regardless of whether it is out of date or not. This is not the correct behavior.

RESOLUTION

Fortunately, the problem above is easy to correct. NMAKE performs correctly if two colons (::) are placed after the target NEW.LIB on the dependency line. The NMAKE file may be rewritten as follows so that the $? macro will work with NMAKE 1.11:


   new.lib::a.obj b.obj c.obj
      !lib $@-+$?;

The use of the $? macro is described on page 108 of the "Microsoft C Advanced Programming Techniques" manual included with C version 6.00. The use of the two colons on the dependency line is described on page 109.

STATUS

Microsoft has confirmed this to be a problem in NMAKE version 1.11. This problem was corrected in NMAKE version 1.12.

MORE INFORMATION

To re-create this problem, save the following lines to a file called MAKEFILE:


   new.lib: a.obj b.obj c.obj
       !lib $@-+$?;

Assuming that only A.OBJ is out of date with respect to NEW.LIB, the following will be produced upon running NMAKE:

NMAKE 1.00 or 1.12:
```
      lib new.lib-+a.obj; 
```

NMAKE 1.11:


      lib new.lib-+a.obj
      lib new.lib-+b.obj
      lib new.lib-+c.obj

Example 1 above shows the correct function of the $? macro.

Additional query words: buglist1.11 fixlist1.12

Keywords : kb16bitonly
Version : MS-DOS:1.11; OS/2:1.11
Platform : MS-DOS OS/2
Issue type :