Comparing Different Implementations of RAID Levels

There are advantages and disadvantages to using the various implementations of RAID (redundant array of independent disks).

RAID implementation Advantage Disadvantage
Microsoft® Windows NT®-based striping No added hardware cost. Uses system processing resources.
Hardware-based striping Does not compete for processor cycles. Best performance of all RAID implementations. Additional cost of specialized hardware.

RAID solutions typically used with Microsoft SQL Server™ provide varying levels of redundancy and fault tolerance.

RAID implementation Advantage Disadvantage
Hardware-based RAID 3, 5, or 10 Excellent performance. Does not compete for processor cycles. Cost.
Hardware-based RAID 1 Excellent redundancy. Does not compete for processor cycles. Additional cost due to more hardware.
Hardware-based RAID 10 Excellent performance. Excellent redundancy. Additional cost due to more hardware.
Windows NT-based RAID 1 Good redundancy. Low cost. Uses system processing resources.
Windows NT-based RAID 5 Excellent read performance. Low cost. Uses system processing resources.

  


(c) 1988-98 Microsoft Corporation. All Rights Reserved.